Welcome to BaseballScenarios.com, the site for baseball fans who want to know what would have, could have or should have happened with their favorite teams. We sim the scenario and give the results back to you, our readers. Enjoy!!

Pick a scenario category above to read our existing posts. Don't see a scenario you'd like to read about? Let us know and we'll make it happen!!

1905 New York Giants Top All

The first season of the Epic Scenario, The .600 Club, has been completed in the year 1900. Champions have been crowned on all eighteen levels of this epic league and some teams are preparing to either be promoted or relegated based on their performance. Now, keep in mind, this was the first of many seasons. Some key players were injured, leading some teams to under perform. Here is a list of all of the league championship match ups. Majors: 1905 New York Giants over the 1948 Cleveland Indians, 4 games to 1. AAA: International League: 1931 St. Louis Cardinals over

1919 World Series Replay

          With the debate about whether Shoeless Joe Jackson should be reinstated by Major League Baseball, it is time to travel back to 1919 and the World Series between Jackson’s Chicago White Sox and the Cincinnati Reds. Most every baseball fan knows the story about how Shoeless Joe and seven teammates took money from gamblers and threw the series, leading to their banishment from baseball following the 1920 season. Now, favorites have lost to underdogs throughout the history of sports. Could the Reds have taken the series without the White Sox helping them out? On paper,

1945 Season Replay

For this scenario, we travel back to 1945. The Cardinals were in the midst of a dynasty, winning the National League the previous three seasons and bringing home two World Series titles. But in 1945, St. Louis was without their star player, Stan Musial. Even without him, the Cardinals challenged for the National League pennant, but finished three games behind the rival Chicago Cubs. Now, Cardinals fans will argue, even to this day, that if Musial had played instead of serving in the military, the Cubs would never have won the pennant. It was also the last season the Cubs

The .600 Club

When it comes to conversations about which team was the best to ever play the game, many arguments can be made for a particular team. Did the team in question win the most games in their league? Did the team win the World Series? If so, was it in seven games or a sweep? And how does one decide the cutoff between a “really good” team and a “great” team? Well, the line has to be drawn somewhere and the line, for me, was at a .600 winning percentage or higher. We’ll call them the .600 Club. When I set

The 1985 I-70 Series Revisited

Thirty years ago, the Kansas City Royals and the St. Louis Cardinals faced off in the 1985 World Series, in what would commonly be called the I-70 Series. The Cardinals fell short in 2014 of making a rematch a possibility, but the 2015 season is looking promising. Will there be a rematch this year? I guess we’ll find out. For this Series Scenario, the 1985 World Series between the teams will be replayed. Will the Royals take the Series in seven games as they did in real life or will the Cardinals redeem themselves and show they were really the